Showtime television's reality 'Candidate' losing by a landslide
Aside from the obvious flaws inherent in this article (exactly how is a premium cable channel like Showtime supposed to - or even
expected to - compete with basic cable a majority of the time? Then again, this
was pulled from the wire services),
American Candidate seems like a decent concept but I'm not a fan of the execution of this show. Mind you, having not seen it yet I don't know if I have a reason to talk about it, but that's never stopped me before. Heh.
First of all, some of the people picked for this show seem to have been selected for the express purpose of controversy, which is all fine and good but...PETA? Out of all the groups one could pick for this show,
American Candidate has to pick one of the most obnoxious, beat-its-message-over-your-head organisations out there today? Fabulous. Perhaps we'll see a man in a pig suit roll around in the hay screaming "PORK BARRELS!" or something. Chrissy Gephardt is also one of the main draws of the program (well, not anymore...she got voted off - yes, yet another reality show that
votes people off one by one) but considering Gephardt's Democratic campaign sank like a stone in the midst of Dean/Kerrymania this wasn't a good choice in retrospect. In fact, this show seems like it's filled with men of failed presidential runs. I wouldn't go describing
"a team of political all-stars" and then following that statement by listing off "Joe Trippi, who ran Howard Dean's presidential campaign, Carter Eskew, chief strategist for Vice President Al Gore's run for president, Ed Rollins, who advised Presidents Nixon, Ford and Regan and Bay Buchanan, sister and campaign manager for her brother Pat Buchanan." Oh boy, the guy who couldn't keep Howard Dean from screaming and Pat Buchanan's sister? Seems like Ed Rollins is the only marketable guy in the bunch, at least to me. Since when was Pat Buchanan a viable threat to the presidency,
ever? Bay's probably only there for the exposure.
Also, the whole
"ordinary people running for office" thing has been done before, and as I recall it didn't come off too well.
Who Wants To Be Governor of California?, as far as I know, tanked for
the Game Show Network GSN: The Network For Excess Reruns of
Love Connection and
Dog Eat Dog, and there was way more potential for a political reality show there than in
American Candidate. Thing is,
American Candidate could be an interesting show if different than what was out there before. Still, there's something about having Gary Coleman and other B-to-ZZZ-list celebrities whore themselves that turned people against the California recall, and I don't think a show like
American Candidate can survive unless it seperates itself from that failed experiment.
The thing that worries me the most, though, is the obvious red flag of this show having been shopped around a bit. This thing was supposed to air on FX two years ago with more of a push than the current series is getting - the winner of the proposed 2002 show was to actually run for President. These days the ten politicos are going for $200,000 and "a 'nationwide media appearance' to address the country" according to the Reuters PR pap. That is a comedown, isn't it? Not exactly thrilling to win $200,000 considering the infamy and/or deep pockets of, say, Gephardt, openly gay Clinton aide Keith Boykin or Richard Mack ("the author of
From My Cold Dead Fingers: Why America Needs Guns -- and a proponent of legalizing marijuana.")
[Washington Post] Methinks there's more a chance for infamy than some schlub winning what could be tit money to him/her. Sadly, the show
probably won't be the catalyst to national infamy, given the ratings.
I give
American Candidate a D. It could be interesting, but my intuition tells me this show's spent too long in turnaround and has gone rotten. Still, there are worse shows.